Skip to Content

Why Are Math Scores Recovering More Slowly Than Reading Scores?

By

Summary of Insights  

  • Math achievement recovery continues to lag behind reading recovery, particularly for middle and high school students, and students that may not have had as much exposure to math concepts.  

  • Strong math outcomes depend on teachers having deep content knowledge and understanding how mathematical skills develop across grade levels.  

  • High-quality instructional materials are most effective when paired with sustained professional learning, coaching and implementation support.  

  • Students are more likely to engage and persist in mathematics when they develop positive math mindsets and see themselves as capable math learners.  

  • Sustainable math improvement requires coordinated investment in teacher development, curriculum implementation and school culture rather than short-term interventions alone.


There has been some good news recently about the recovery of reading scores following years of sluggishness: the gap in Measures of Academic Progress (MAP) reading scores for K-8 students has narrowed from pre-pandemic levels by one-third in the past year, according to a new study by NWEA.1 The improvement is part of a larger trend, resulting from a significant push across education agencies and policy makers to align literacy instruction with research-backed principles, collectively known as the science of reading. Educators have accompanied these instructional methods with early intervention policies, increased tutoring and resources, and targeted professional development for teachers.  

Math scores, unfortunately, present a more complicated picture. Despite some growth in MAP scores in the early post-pandemic years, scores have stagnated for middle and high school students, and elementary students are showing uneven, partial recovery. Some of the biggest achievement gaps are experienced by the lowest performing students across socio-economic and racial groups.2  Similar trends, gains in reading and lag in math, have also been seen in NAEP’s biannual Nation’s Report Card.3   

The post-pandemic disparity between students’ reading and math achievement isn’t surprising, given the attention and resources devoted to improving reading instruction. States are now starting to use a similar playbook when creating policies to improve math outcomes, mandating early intervention practices, encouraging the use of high-quality instructional materials and/or promoting policies that encourage automatic enrollment in advanced math pathways.   

The case for a science of math instructional movement that mirrors its literacy counterpart, however, is more controversial. The debate around the science of math movement is the latest skirmish in a decades-long debate on how to teach math. How to prioritize or sequence direct instruction versus more conceptual, inquiry-based methods has become heated, generating what seems like “1000 takes” across the math community.4 Effective math instruction feels particularly fraught in an era where math achievement for our most vulnerable students remains stubbornly low.5 

Hot takes aside, there is substantial research on proven practices that leaders can enact to create the conditions for stronger math outcomes for students. To this end, there are three areas district and building leaders might consider when looking to launch a math improvement strategy:  

  1. Build Teachers’ Content Knowledge and Pedagogical Content Knowledge 
    The cumulative nature of mathematics demands that teachers have a deep understanding of math content and skill development, and teachers need content-specific professional learning.  
     
    MIT professor Steven Pinker described math as “ruthlessly cumulative,” meaning that students will struggle with math if they miss learning foundational skills and concepts.6 Researchers have noted the connection between teachers’ content knowledge and their understanding of math skill progressions with students’ math achievement.7 Teachers who have a clear understanding of how math skills build across grade levels are better able to diagnose what foundational skills students might be missing or how to connect students’ prior knowledge to new content.  
     
    Yet teachers with specialized math knowledge are becoming harder to find, particularly for hard-to-fill elementary and middle school math positions. At a time when more districts are using under-certified or alternatively certified math teachers to fill classroom vacancies,8 professional learning that improves teachers’ math content knowledge becomes even more essential.  
     

  2. Implement Strong, High-Quality Math Curricula 
    Using high-quality instructional materials (HQIM) helps drive outcomes, but effective implementation matters.  
     
    High-quality instructional materials help teachers implement standards-aligned materials and ensure that students are exposed to grade-level tasks and activities. They also help teachers with the important skill progression and development discussed above. Research on the impact of HQIM on student outcomes is well established, particularly for students of early-career teachers.9  
     
    As HQIM have been adopted more broadly, we’ve also learned that the quality of implementation support can make all the difference for student outcomes. Most teachers tasked with implementing HQIM only received, on average, 1-3 days of professional development dedicated to understanding their curriculum—a dosage which isn’t conducive to change practice or to support teacher buy-in on the curriculum’s value.10 For HQIM to be impactful, leaders should look for professional learning that  targets understanding of lesson design and content, prioritize more opportunities for teachers to “try on” materials and offer teachers more feedback from peers, coaches and administrators on implementation.   
     

  3. Strengthen Teachers’ and Students’ Own Math Mindsets 
    Student math mindsets form early. We need to help students see themselves as “math people.”   
     
    In a recent RAND survey, about half of middle school and high school students reported losing interest in math lessons most of the time, and around a third said they do not identify as a “math person” or “good in math.”11  This attitude about math starts early: students report feeling anxiety about math as early as elementary school, and they identify as either good or bad at math by the time they are ready for middle school.12  
     
    Having a positive math mindset is especially impactful for students who have been historically sidelined in math classrooms, such as female students, students experiencing poverty, or Black and Latino students.13  
     
    Teachers’ own mindsets about whether math is “hard”—or whether only some students can learn math well—are important indicators for how students will regard the subject, particularly for those in elementary settings.13 Leaders in elementary and middle school divisions might consider launching culture and mindset programming for teachers, during which they explore the power of building students’ self-image and confidence as math students as well as the impact of their own attitudes about math on instruction and culture building.  

 

Is Building a Sustainable and Positive Math Culture Worth the Investment?  

These system and building-level initiatives take time, but they are essential for sustained math improvement. Math recovery requires more than targeted interventions and short-term programs. Districts that want elevated math outcomes should focus on strengthening teacher content knowledge, effective implementation of high-quality instructional materials and supporting positive math mindsets. Together, these create the conditions that support stronger instruction, greater student engagement and more consistent achievement. Districts that invest in all three areas build a stronger foundation for math learning across grade levels, helping more students develop the confidence, skills and understanding needed to succeed in math—now and in the future.  

  

Strengthen Math Learning Across Grade Levels  

Improving math outcomes requires more than strong instruction in a single classroom or grade level. Vertical Team Training helps districts align instruction across grade levels, identify gap, strengthen collaboration and build coherent pathways that prepare students for success in advanced coursework and beyond. 

Explore Vertical Team Training

  1. Kuhfeld, Megan and Lewis, Karyn. “Turning a corner in reading: MAP Growth data shows reading improvements after period of post-COVID stagnation.” NWEA Research Brief. Sept 26, 2026.  

  2. Mervosh, Sarah. “The Pandemic Is Not the Only Reason U.S. Students Are Losing Ground.” New York Times. April 7, 2026.  

  3. U.S. Department of Education, Institute of Education Sciences, National Center for Education Statistics. (2025). NAEP Long-Term Trend Assessment Results: Reading and Mathematics. National Assessment of Educational Progress (NAEP). https://www.nationsreportcard.gov/ltt/2025/  

  4. Williams, Conor P. “ ‘Sold a Story’ Season 2: Teachers and Schools Matter. We Should Act Like It.” The74. October 15, 2026. 

  5. Schwartz, Sarah. “Debates Over Math Teaching Are Heating Up. They Could Affect Classrooms.” EdWeek. Jan 26, 2026.  

  6. Kerns, Gene. “The truth about fluency and the promise of differentiated practice.” Renaissance. Blog. Sept 3, 2015.  

  7. Fusaro, Maria. “How Math Knowledge Leads to Better Math Teaching.” Harvard Graduate School of Education. July 24, 2008.  

  8. “An Overview of Teacher Shortages: 2026.” Learning Policy Institute Fact Sheet. July 13, 2026.  

  9. Berlin, Rebekah and Zhou, CeCe. “Prioritizing Use of HQIM Among Aspiring and First-Year Teachers.” Score. October 12, 2022.  

  10. Steiner, David. “The Unrealized Promise of High-Quality Instructional Materials.” State Education Standard. 24:1. January 2024.  

  11. Price, H., & Fitz, J. (2026). Math for every student: Cultivating math mindsets in middle school [Brief] Learning Policy Institute. June 30, 2026.  

  12. Weir, Kirsten. “How to Help Kids Manage Math Anxiety.” American Psychological Society. August 2025. 

  13. Crawford, Krysten. “When teachers think differently about themselves as math learners, students benefit.” Research Stories. Stanford Graduate School of Education. July 12, 2018. 

Why are math scores recovering more slowly than reading scores? The reasons vary across districts and student populations, but mathematics learning is highly cumulative. Students who miss foundational skills often struggle with more advanced concepts, making recovery more challenging. Math instruction has also not benefited from the same level of coordinated policy attention and instructional alignment that has supported literacy improvement in many states.  

What role does teacher content knowledge play in math achievement?  Teachers with strong mathematics content knowledge and an understanding of how mathematical skills progress across grade levels are better equipped to identify gaps, connect prior learning to new concepts and support student mastery. Research has consistently linked teacher content expertise to stronger student outcomes in mathematics.  

Are high-quality instructional materials enough to improve math outcomes? No. High-quality instructional materials provide an important foundation, but implementation matters. Teachers need professional learning, opportunities to practice, and ongoing feedback to effectively use instructional materials and translate them into improved student learning experiences. 

What is a math mindset?  A math mindset refers to how students view their ability to learn and succeed in mathematics. Students who believe they can grow and improve in math are often more willing to engage with challenging content and persist when they encounter difficulty.  

Why should school leaders focus on teacher mindsets about math?  Students often take cues from the adults around them. Teachers who view mathematics as learnable and believe all students can succeed in math help create classroom cultures that encourage confidence, persistence, and engagement. 

How can districts improve math instruction across grade levels?  Districts can strengthen math instruction by investing in teacher content knowledge, supporting effective curriculum implementation, aligning instruction across grade levels, and creating opportunities for educators to collaborate around student learning progressions.  

Why is vertical alignment important in mathematics? Mathematics learning builds over time. Vertical alignment helps educators understand how concepts and skills develop across grade levels, reducing instructional gaps and ensuring students are prepared for increasingly complex mathematics.